Classified CIA “Mea Culpa” for “Mistakes on Iraqi WMD and Intentions”
Please Note that this is of course more cover-up. The Bush Administration, with the assistance of some Democrats, specially created the Office of Special Plans and other sub-rosa units to guarantee that none of the usual vetting or counter-voices on intelligence requested to support a case for War could surface or challenge the case and pretexts for war and regime change laid out in the PNAC documents. CIA towed the line and even their own say so that they kept quiet and pimped the case and pretexts for illegal, aggressive wars and regime changes of the kind Nazis were hanged for at Nuremberg.
Saddam Hussein was a creature of CIA and did their bidding at times wittingly and other times unwittingly. But these interviews and this de-classified report are very interesting and revealing for today’s issues and crises that flow from or have been magnified by these layers of imperialist intrigue.
National Security Archive Electronic Briefing Book No. 279
Edited by Joyce Battle
Assisted by Brendan McQuade
Posted – July 1, 2009
For more information contact:
Joyce Battle – 202/994-7145
In the news
“Hussein Pointed to Iranian Threat”
By Glenn Kessler
The Washington Post
July 2, 2009
“Saddam denied al Qaeda ties till the end”
By Eli Lake
The Washington Times
July 2, 2009
“FBI says Saddam’s weapons bluff aimed at Iran”
By JoAnne Allen
July 2, 2009
“FBI Releases Details of 2004 Talks with Saddam Hussein”
Voice of America
July 2, 2009
“FBI releases summaries of interviews with Saddam Hussein”
July 2, 2009
“Former Iraqi leader Saddam Hussein bluffed about WMDs fearing Iranian arsenal, secret FBI files show”
By James Gordon Meek
New York Daily News
June 24, 2009
PR Push for Iraq War Preceded Intelligence Findings
“White Paper” Drafted before NIE even Requested
U.S. Military Hoped for Virtually Unlimited Freedom of Action in Iraq
Drafting of U.S.-Iraq Security Agreement Began Nearly Five Years Ago
The Record on CURVEBALL
Declassified Documents and Key Participants Show the Importance of Phony Intelligence in the Origins of the Iraq War
TOP SECRET POLO STEP
Iraq War Plan Assumed Only 5,000 U.S. Troops Still There by December 2006
Post-Saddam Iraq: The War Game
“Desert Crossing” 1999 Assumed 400,000 Troops and Still a Mess
New State Department Releases on the “Future of Iraq” Project
New Documents Provide Details on Budgets, Interagency Coordination and Working Group Progress
Saddam’s Iron Grip
Intelligence Reports on Saddam Hussein’s Reign
State Department experts warned CENTCOM before Iraq war about lack of plans for post-war Iraq security
Planning for post-Saddam regime change began as early as October 2001
CIA Whites Out Controversial Estimate on Iraq Weapons
Main Subject of Today’s Senate Intelligence Report Remains Largely Secret
The Saddam Hussein Sourcebook
Declassified secrets from the U.S.-Iraq relationship
Eyes on Saddam
U.S. overhead imagery of Iraq
Shaking Hands with Saddam Hussein
The U.S. tilts toward Iraq, 1980-1984
Iraq and Weapons of Mass Destruction
Operation Desert Storm: Ten Years After
Documents shed light on role of intelligence, stealth technology and space systems in the Gulf War
Washington, D.C., July 1, 2009 – FBI special agents carried out 20 formal interviews and at least 5 “casual conversations” with former Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein after his capture by U.S. troops in December 2003, according to secret FBI reports released as the result of Freedom of Information Act requests by the National Security Archive and posted today on the Web at http://www.nsarchive.org.
Saddam denied any connections to the “zealot” Osama bin Laden, cited North Korea as his most likely ally in a crunch, and shared President George W. Bush’s hostility towards the “fanatic” Iranian mullahs, according to the FBI records of conversations from February through June 2004 between Saddam and Arabic-speaking agents in his detention cell at Baghdad International Airport.
The former Iraqi leader, when asked about his accomplishments, listed social progress for the people of Iraq, a temporary truce with the Kurds in the early 1970s, the nationalization of Iraq’s oil in 1972, support for the Arab side during the 1973 Middle East war with Israel, and after that, for the remaining 30 years of his rule, simple survival – through a devastating eight year war with Iran that he had launched, and a 12-year sanctions regime imposed on his people after another war that he began. During the interviews he repeatedly contests FBI evidence and the neutrality of his interlocutors – which one of them finds ironic, given the record of peremptory Iraqi justice under Saddam’s governance. He selectively outlines recent Iraqi history and acknowledges some mistakes, including the destruction without U.N. supervision or verification of some of Iraq’s WMD arsenal left over from the 1980s.
During the interviews Saddam refutes some examples of what he views as myths, like his purported use of body doubles. Instead he says that to evade his enemies he never used the telephone and traveled constantly from one dwelling to another (he describes the farm where he was captured in a “spider hole” as the same place where he took refuge after a failed 1959 coup attempt.)
He takes personal responsibility for ordering the launching of SCUD missiles against Israeli targets during the 1991 Persian Gulf War, because he blamed Israel and its influence in the U.S. for “all the problems of the Arabs”, but denies that his purpose was to draw that country into the conflict and to divide Washington from its Arab allies. He provides details on the lead-up to the war, reporting that during a January 1991 meeting former Secretary of State James Baker told Saddam’s foreign minister that if Iraq did not comply with U.S. conditions “we’ll take you back to the pre-industrial stage.”
Saddam’s historical recollections include his ascendancy within the Ba’athist party in 1968 and 1969; his disappointment after the Iran-Iraq war with Arab governments for their lack of gratitude for Iraq’s “saving all of the Arab world” from occupation by Iran; details about the 1991 Persian Gulf war; and the post-war Shi’a uprising in Iraq’s south, which he characterizes as “treachery” instigated by Iran.
Not included in these FBI reports are issues of particular interest to students of Iraq’s complicated relationship with the U.S. – the reported role of the CIA in facilitating the Ba’ath party’s rise to power, the uneasy alliance forged between Iraq and the U.S. during the Iran-Iraq war, and the precise nature of U.S. views regarding Iraq’s chemical weapons policy during that conflict, given its contemporaneous knowledge of their repeated use against Iranians and the Kurds.
This series of interviews also does not address chemical warfare in Kurdish areas of Iraq in 1987-1988, although an FBI progress report says Saddam was questioned on the topic. One interview, #20, is redacted in its entirety on national security grounds, although it is not clear what issues agents could have discussed with Saddam that cannot now be disclosed to the public.
The interviews and conversations were led by George L. Piro, one of an exceedingly small number of FBI agents who spoke Arabic. The agency expected that Saddam would feel rapport with Piro and develop a sense of dependency. During the interviews Piro hears Saddam out but is often openly skeptical of the former leader’s recollections. The agent does, however, assert with confidence that the U.S. side had information that Iraq was maintaining or developing a WMD capability and cites “evidence” of continuing contact between Iran and al-Qaeda, seemingly implying an operational relationship.
Saddam does not provide comfort to his interlocutors on these matters, refuting any notion of collaboration with al-Qaeda, or of a remaining WMD capacity, and in reality the charges, meant to win public support for the invasion of Iraq, were collapsing while the interviews were underway. Investigators from the CIA, operating freely in occupied Iraq, failed to uncover any credible supporting evidence for the U.S. claims, and ultimately President Bush himself acknowledged that “most of the intelligence turned out to be wrong.”
One of the last interviews in the series ends on a valedictory note, after Piro listens to a poem that Saddam had written. The former president of Iraq is “done,” Piro says, “his life is nearing its end,” and other detainees are blaming him for all of Iraq’s many mistakes. Saddam is fatalistic and acknowledges reality. His interviews with Piro ended soon thereafter, and on December 30, 2006, he was hanged, amid the taunts of the political enemies who carried out his execution.
Read the Documents
Note: The following documents are in PDF format.
You will need to download and install the free Adobe Acrobat Reader to view.
FBI Form, January 1, 2004
Interview Session 1, February 7, 2004
Interview Session 2, February 8, 2004
Interview Session 3, February 10, 2004
Interview Session 4, February 13, 2004
Interview Session 5, February 15, 2004
Interview Session 6, February 16, 2004
Interview Session 7, February 18, 2004
Interview Session 8, February 20, 2004
Interview Session 9, February 24, 2004
Interview Session 10, February 27, 2004
Interview Session 11, March 3, 2004
Interview Session 12, March 5, 2004
Interview Session 13, March 11, 2004
Interview Session 14, March 13, 2004
Interview Session 15, March 16, 2004
Interview Session 16, March 19, 2004
Interview Session 17, March 23, 2004
Interview Session 18, March 28, 2004
Interview Session 19, March 30, 2004
Interview Session 20, May 1, 2004
Casual Conversation, May 10, 2004
Casual Conversation, May13, 2004
Casual Conversation, June 11, 2004
Casual Conversation, June 17, 2004
Casual Conversation, June 28, 2004
[Excised] IT-Iraq, March 21, 2004